Back to all lyrics
Artwork for How Shall I Give Thee Up?

Hosea 11:1-12

How Shall I Give Thee Up?

Lyrics · Hosea

How Shall I Give Thee Up?

Hosea 11:1-12

Lyrics

About this song

About this song

This song belongs to the Hosea collection. One recording is available to play here, with the complete lyrics below.

Bible book
Hosea
Collection
Hosea
Musical styles
Uncategorized
[Oracle] I taught him to walk with his hand in mine, I lifted the yoke and bent down with bread. The prophets kept calling; the child ran away, [People] The sword at the gate was the harvest of counsel, A heart bent backward could not call exile peace. [Oracle] And bowed to the shapes his own fingers had made. Then over the sentence compassion was stirred: How shall I give thee up? How shall love cease? Not Admah again, not Zeboim’s end, [People] The sword at the gate was the harvest of counsel, A heart bent backward could not call exile peace. The Holy One stands in the midst of the land. [Bridge] A lion will call and the children will come, Trembling like birds toward the doors of their homes. Love does not rename rebellion as right, [Coda] But mercy remembers the child through the night. The sword at the gate was the harvest of counsel, A heart bent backward could not call exile peace.

About the passage

Hosea 11: The one who taught the child to walk refuses the last word of ruin

The Lord remembers Israel as a child loved, called from Egypt, taught to walk, healed, drawn, and fed. The intimacy of those memories makes the repeated failure to recognize the giver more, not less, serious. Israel answers calling by moving toward Baalim and refuses the return urged throughout the book, so Assyrian rule and the sword enter the chapter as consequences. Then the divine speech itself changes direction. Faced with the prospect of giving Ephraim up like Admah and Zeboim, compassion rises within the speech and complete destruction is refused. The reason given is God's own identity: "God, and not man," the Holy One still in the midst of the people. Earlier images are then reversed. The lion's roar gathers rather than tears, and trembling birds return from Egypt and Assyria to be placed again in their houses.

Study Hosea 11 in depth