New · FreePlay The Witnesses The in-depth puzzle battle quest through Bible history

The City That Has No Comforter

Lamentations 1

The big picture

Lamentations 1 makes absence audible. Jerusalem is measured against what used to fill her: people, feasts, allies, children, leaders, food, and honor. Even the roads and gates seem to register what no longer arrives. Yet the city does not remain a distant object under inspection. Her own voice interrupts the description and repeatedly asks the Lord and the surrounding world to look. She acknowledges rebellion and the Lord's righteousness without treating that confession as a reason to minimize captivity, hunger, betrayal, or death. The chapter's controlling ache is the missing comforter. Former lovers fail, enemies rejoice, and no human relationship repairs what has collapsed. The final prayer therefore holds two claims together: Jerusalem's transgressions are real, and the wickedness of those who delight in her ruin is also brought before God.

Central truth

Jerusalem’s grieving voice acknowledges the Lord’s righteous judgment and her allies’ betrayal while asking both passersby and the Lord to see her desolation.

Lamentations 1: The City That Has No Comforter
Chapter sceneLamentations 1

The study notes have a page of their own

The movement by movement analysis, the words to trace, the verse by verse notes and where readers differ are written for someone studying alone. They are on the Deep Personal Reflections page for this chapter. This page is the lesson.

A chapter-specific teaching brief

These anchors come from this chapter itself. They help a teacher use the Level 1 overview, the Level 2 study, and the Scripture text as one lesson.

1

Open with the chapter’s first image

Lamentations 1:1: “How doth the city sit solitary, that was full of people! how is she become as a widow! she that was great among the nations, and princess among the…”

2

Slow down at the turning point

Lamentations 1:12: “Is it nothing to you, all ye that pass by? behold, and see if there be any sorrow like unto my sorrow, which is done unto me, wherewith the LORD hath…”

3

Keep this word trail visible

LORD, become, enemy, gone, people, adversaries

What to explain, in order

Teach the passage in this order. Each step names the verses it rests on, so every point can be shown in the text before it is applied.

  1. Lamentations 1:1-3

    Begin with the cry of How

    Open with the first word. "How" is the Hebrew ekah, which became the book's Hebrew name, a cry of disbelief rather than a request for information. Read 1:1 and set out its three reversals on the board: full and solitary, great and widowed, princess and tributary. Then 1:2-3 add tears at night, faithless friends, and Judah in captivity where "she findeth no rest". Teach this first because the Book of Lamentations lets you see the ruin before it explains anything, and a class that hears guilt before it has seen loss will listen to the rest with folded arms. Mention also that the chapter is an acrostic: its twenty two verses begin with the letters of the Hebrew alphabet in order, so grief is given a shape from first letter to last.

  2. Lamentations 1:4-7

    Empty roads and a remembered past

    Move to what is missing. The roads to Zion mourn because none come to the solemn feasts, the appointed festivals that once filled them. Gates, priests and young women are all named, so the loss runs through worship, civic life and the next generation. Then point to the first explanation in the book, in 1:5: "for the LORD hath afflicted her for the multitude of her transgressions". Do not hurry past it, and do not make it the whole chapter either. In 1:7 Jerusalem remembers "all her pleasant things that she had in the days of old", and the enemies "did mock at her sabbaths". Memory makes the present worse. Explain sabbaths here as her holy days, now a joke to those who watch.

  3. Lamentations 1:8-11

    Sin named, and a voice that breaks in

    This movement states the guilt plainly, "Jerusalem hath grievously sinned", and uses the language of exposure: her nakedness seen, her filthiness in her skirts. Explain these as images of public shame, and read them without dwelling. Then show the interruption. In the middle of 1:9 the city cuts across the description with "O LORD, behold my affliction", and again in 1:11 with "see, O LORD, and consider". Between them, 1:10 records foreigners entering the sanctuary, which Deuteronomy 23:3 had barred from the congregation, and 1:11 shows people trading their treasures for food. Explain meat as food in general. Teach the interruptions here because they prepare for 1:12, where the city takes over the speaking.

  4. Lamentations 1:12-17

    Is it nothing to you

    Now the city speaks to the passers by. Read "Is it nothing to you, all ye that pass by" slowly and let the room sit with it. The images that follow put the action in the Lord's hands: fire in the bones, a net spread for the feet, "The yoke of my transgressions is bound by his hand", and the young trodden "as in a winepress". Explain the yoke as sins tied together into one burden on the neck. In 1:16 she weeps, "mine eye, mine eye runneth down with water", and in 1:17 the Book of Lamentations steps back for one verse: Zion spreads out her hands and there is none to comfort her. Explain "as a menstruous woman" as ritual uncleanness, someone others keep their distance from, and say no more than that.

  5. Lamentations 1:18-22

    A righteous judge, faithless lovers, an open ending

    Close the exposition with the verse that holds the chapter together. In 1:18 the city says the Lord is righteous and in the same breath asks all people to behold her sorrow. Then the losses continue: lovers who deceived, priests and elders who died searching for food, and in 1:20 the line "abroad the sword bereaveth, at home there is as death". The chapter ends with an appeal that the enemies, who were glad at her trouble, be judged by the same measure she has been. Teach this last and leave it open. Nothing in chapter 1 is resolved, no comforter arrives, and the lesson should end where the chapter does rather than borrowing the hope of chapter 3.

Where learners get stuck

The misreadings this passage tends to produce, and how to answer each from the text.

"If Jerusalem admits she sinned, her grief does not really matter."

Read 1:18 aloud and stop at the colon. The same verse that says "The LORD is righteous" goes on to ask "all people" to "behold my sorrow". The Book of Lamentations does not set confession against grief; it lets the confession make the grief honest. Point out that the confessions (1:5, 1:8, 1:14, 1:20) and the cries to be seen (1:9, 1:11, 1:12, 1:20) are woven through the same chapter, so a reader cannot keep one and throw away the other.

"God is only watching while Babylon does this to Jerusalem."

Babylon is never named in Lamentations, and the chapter puts the main verbs in the Lord's hands: he "hath afflicted her" (1:5), "From above hath he sent fire into my bones" (1:13), "The Lord hath trodden under foot all my mighty men" (1:15). The enemies act too, and are guilty of gloating (1:21-22). Hold both. The book insists that the Lord is at work in the disaster and that the human agents remain accountable for their cruelty.

"The woman in this chapter is a real widow who lived in Jerusalem."

She is the city itself, given a woman's voice. The chapter calls her "the daughter of Zion" (1:6) and names her Jerusalem (1:7, 1:8, 1:17). Personification lets a whole people grieve in one voice and lets the reader hear the city as a person rather than a set of statistics. That matters pastorally: the widow image honours the real widows of the siege without pretending to be any one of them.

"Lamentations 1:12 is really about Jesus on the cross."

In the chapter the speaker is Jerusalem, and two verses later she says "The yoke of my transgressions is bound by his hand" (1:14), then confesses in 1:18 "I have rebelled against his commandment". Those are not words Christians put on the lips of Christ. Many have heard an echo of the cross in 1:12, and you may say so, but teach it as a comparison made later, not as what the verse means. Let Jerusalem's own grief be heard first.

Learning objectives

  1. Identify the reversals in Jerusalem’s opening portrait.
  2. Explain why the roads to Zion mourn.
  3. Trace the repeated absence of a comforter.
  4. Distinguish Jerusalem’s confession from her enemies’ cruelty.
  5. Describe how the city receives a speaking voice.
  6. Recognize lament that ends without visible relief.

Teacher preparation

  1. Read 2 Kings 25:8–21 before teaching the ruined city’s lament.
  2. Mark the shifts into first-person speech, including the appeals already present in 1:9 and 1:11.
  3. Explain tributary as subject to tribute and meat in 1:11 as food.
  4. Prepare to explain personification without treating the grieving woman as a separately identified resident.
  5. Plan quiet reading rather than dramatic impersonation of bereavement or captivity.

Evidence and interpretation checks

Explicit

Read 1:1–4 and 1:18: Jerusalem has lost population, standing, and worshippers, and explicitly acknowledges rebellion against the Lord.

Scripture-supported

Pair 1:5 with 1:18 and 1:22; the chapter identifies transgression while also naming the enemies’ wickedness.

Strong inference

Trace the missing comforter in 1:2, 9, 16, 17, 21; infer that isolation intensifies the grief rather than treating the repetition as filler.

Possible or traditional reading

Present a Christian comparison between the suffering appeal in 1:12 and Christ’s suffering as a comparison, not identification; Jerusalem confesses her own rebellion in 1:18.

Limit

Keep 1:21–22 unresolved: the appeal requests judgment, but this chapter neither records relief nor tells us every sufferer’s individual responsibility.

Discussion with answer guidance

1. How does the city move from princess to widow in the opening verse?

What a good answer contains

Verse 1 is built on three reversals: the city "that was full of people" now sits solitary, she that was "great among the nations" is become as a widow, and the "princess among the provinces" is become tributary, paying tribute to another power. A good answer names all three pairs and sees that population, protection and standing have all gone at once. Widow is personification: the city has lost the one who should have defended her. A weak answer pictures a literal royal widow, or hears only an economic decline.

Show teacher guidance

Compare the paired descriptions in 1:1: populous and solitary, great and tributary; explain personification without inventing a literal royal widow.

2. Why do the roads to Zion mourn when roads cannot feel?

What a good answer contains

The roads mourn "because none come to the solemn feasts" (1:4). These were the pilgrim roads that filled at the appointed festivals; now nobody walks them, so the empty road becomes a picture of the missing worshippers. The same verse adds desolate gates, sighing priests and afflicted virgins, so the absence reaches worship, public life and the next generation. A weak answer treats the line as decoration, or claims the roads have feelings, and misses that worship itself has stopped.

Show teacher guidance

Use 1:4: worshippers no longer travel to the feasts. Let the empty route make the missing people visible.

3. What does the repeated absence of a comforter add to the city’s losses?

What a good answer contains

The line comes five times: "she hath none to comfort her" (1:2), "she had no comforter" (1:9), "the comforter that should relieve my soul is far from me" (1:16), "there is none to comfort her" (1:17) and "there is none to comfort me" (1:21). A good answer notices that it moves from third person to first, and that the people who failed her were "lovers" and "friends" who "dealt treacherously with her" (1:2), the allies of 1:19. The loss is abandonment, not only property, and a weak answer counts only what was taken.

Show teacher guidance

Gather 1:2, 9, 16, 17, 21; distinguish loss of possessions from abandonment by supposed friends and lovers.

4. What changes when the city addresses the Lord and the passersby directly?

What a good answer contains

The city stops being a sight and becomes a speaker. Twice she breaks into the description before it is finished, "O LORD, behold my affliction" (1:9) and "see, O LORD, and consider; for I am become vile" (1:11), and then she turns to the road: "Is it nothing to you, all ye that pass by" (1:12). From 1:12 most of the chapter is in her own voice. A strong answer notices she asks first to be seen by the Lord and then by people, and a weak one misses the interruptions in 1:9 and 1:11.

Show teacher guidance

Read the appeals in 1:9, 11–12. Notice how the afflicted city speaks rather than remaining an object viewed from a safe distance.

5. How can Jerusalem confess rebellion and still ask people to behold her sorrow?

What a good answer contains

Because both halves sit in one verse: "The LORD is righteous; for I have rebelled against his commandment: hear, I pray you, all people, and behold my sorrow" (1:18). The confession is real and repeated (1:5, 1:8, 1:14, 1:20), yet it does not end her request to be looked at. A good answer holds both, and sees that admitting guilt is the very thing that lets her speak honestly. A weak answer says she deserved it and so the grief can be ignored, or treats her as wholly innocent.

Show teacher guidance

Keep both halves of 1:18 together. Correct the claim that admitting guilt makes suffering unworthy of attention.

6. Does the request against the enemies cancel Jerusalem’s confession?

What a good answer contains

No. The same prayer that asks "Let all their wickedness come before thee" also says "as thou hast done unto me for all my transgressions" (1:22), so her own wrong is named inside the request. She asks God to apply one measure to everyone, and she hands the matter to him rather than taking it herself. The enemies are guilty of gloating: "they are glad that thou hast done it" (1:21). A weak answer chooses one responsibility, either hers or theirs, and drops the other.

Show teacher guidance

Read 1:21–22 beside 1:18; distinguish acknowledged transgression from the enemies’ rejoicing and wickedness rather than choosing only one responsibility.

Responsible application

Heart and habits

Ask learners to revise a fictional response that dismisses Jerusalem’s grief because she confesses sin; preserve both statements in 1:18.

Relationships and community

Discuss what attentive companionship might offer a displaced community; begin with the repeated lack of comfort rather than easy assurances.

Seeing rather than passing by

Use 1:12 to contrast noticing suffering with consuming it as spectacle; propose respectful wording for a fictional relief appeal.

Session plans

Two timings of the same lesson. The shorter keeps the reading, the central discussion and one response; the longer gives the confusions and the application their own time.

45 minutes

5 min

The first word

Read 1:1-3 aloud slowly. Write the three pairs from 1:1 on the board in two columns, then take question one.

8 min

Empty roads, no comforter

Read 1:4-7 and take question two. Then hunt the five lines about comfort for question three and write each one with its verse.

10 min

The voice breaks in

Read 1:8-17. Ask question four, pointing to the interruptions in 1:9 and 1:11, then deal with confusion two from 1:5, 1:13 and 1:15.

10 min

Righteous, and still grieving

Read 1:18-22. Take questions five and six together, and answer confusion one from the two halves of 1:18.

7 min

Seeing rather than passing by

Work the third application in pairs: draft a respectful sentence about someone else's loss, using 1:12 as the test.

5 min

Handout and a quiet close

Read the key verse together, give out the handout, and close with a short prayer that asks God to see those who grieve. Ask no one to share.

90 minutes

8 min

What helps and what hurts

Ask the group, in general terms only, what people say to the grieving that helps and what wounds. Write two columns and keep them visible.

10 min

The city and its fall

Summarise 2 Kings 25:8-12 in two sentences, explain the acrostic, then read 1:1-3 and take question one.

12 min

The empty road

Read 1:4-11. Take questions two and three, building the comforter list on the board as the verses are found.

12 min

Is it nothing to you

Read 1:12-17 slowly. Take question four, then confusion two on who acts and confusion four on reading 1:12 as about the cross.

15 min

Confession and appeal

Read 1:18-22. Spend real time on questions five and six, then confusion one. Compare the two columns from the opening with what Jerusalem asks for.

8 min

Why a woman's voice

Take confusion three. Ask what is gained when a city speaks as a person, and how that should shape the way we talk about a disaster.

12 min

Seeing rather than passing by

In pairs, complete the third application, then the second. Each pair reads one sentence aloud.

8 min

A written lament

Offer the pattern of the chapter, see, hear, confess, appeal, for anyone who wants to write privately. Nothing is collected or read out.

5 min

Handout and prayer

Read the key verse together and pray for any who are grieving, without naming anyone.

Adapting the lesson

Children

Show a picture of an empty street or playground and ask how a place feels when everyone has gone. Explain that Jerusalem's people lost their homes and the city cried like a sad lady. Read 1:2 and 1:12 only, and leave out 1:8-9 and 1:17. Spend most of the time on what a good comforter does for a sad friend, and never ask children to imagine losing their own parents.

Youth

Begin with scrolling past bad news, and read 1:12 as a question to people who keep walking. Compare two captions for a photograph of a ruined city, one sensational and one attentive, using the third application. Some in the room will have lost someone or watched a family break, so give a written option and let no one be pressed to explain their own grief.

Adults

Give time to the structure: the acrostic, the shift from description to the city's voice at 1:12, and the confession set inside the lament at 1:18. Read 2 Kings 25:8-12 for the events. Then guard the application. The book explains Jerusalem's fall by her covenant rebellion; it does not license anyone to tell a grieving person that a loss is their punishment. Adults who have been told that need to hear the difference.

One to one

If the person is grieving, read 1:12 and 1:16 together and let them sit with it before saying anything. Ask which line sounds most like what they feel. Do not hurry to chapter 3 or supply comfort the chapter withholds, and never connect their loss to sin. Being the comforter who is present, rather than the one who is far off in 1:16, is the lesson here.

Song and video learning lab

A song or video may interpret, compress, or dramatize the text. Its value becomes clearer when its choices are compared with Scripture.

  1. Before the media: the exact passage and its central movement.
  2. During the media: the words, people, events, and emotions the artist emphasizes.
  3. After the media: what it clarifies, what it leaves out, and what belongs back in the biblical text.

Handout

One page for learners to take home. The print button prints this section alone.

Lamentations 1

The passage in brief

Lamentations 1 is a poem of grief over Jerusalem after it was destroyed. The city is pictured as a woman who was once a princess and is now alone, like a widow, with no one to comfort her. Her friends have betrayed her and her people are gone. She admits that she rebelled against the Lord and that he is righteous, and she still asks God and everyone passing by to look at her sorrow. The chapter ends with her prayer still waiting for an answer.

A verse to keep

The LORD is righteous; for I have rebelled against his commandment: hear, I pray you, all people, and behold my sorrow: my virgins and my young men are gone into captivity.

Lamentations 1:18 · King James Version

Questions to take home

  1. Find the five places in Lamentations 1 that say there was no one to comfort Jerusalem. Who should have comforted her?

  2. How can 1:18 say both that the Lord is righteous and that the city's sorrow deserves to be seen?

  3. What would it look like this week not to pass by someone's sorrow?

This week

Choose one person who is grieving this week and give them your attention without trying to explain their loss.

Music and video connected to the passage

Related media appears when its Scripture reference overlaps this study. Music and video can illuminate a theme while the biblical text remains the foundation.

Report an error on this page

Source: eBible.org · eng-kjv2006